(916) 269-0761
Call

Are Insurers Dropping Homes in Wildfire Zones? Non-Renewals by ZIP Code in Sacramento, Tahoe and the Bay Area

By GVD Renovations · CA Lic. #989637Reviewed by Tim Krasniy, Marketing DirectorPublished November 19, 2026Data: CA Dept. of Insurance, CAL FIRE

Where are insurance companies choosing not to renew homeowners' policies, and does it follow the wildfire hazard maps? We matched the Department of Insurance's non-renewal counts for every ZIP code with our count of homes in CAL FIRE's hazard zones.

Key finding
In ZIP codes where more than half of homes sit in a High or Very High fire hazard zone, insurers chose not to renew 4.9% of policies a year in 2019–2021, up from 2.3% in 2015–2017: 2.1 times as many. In ZIP codes with no homes in those zones, the rate went down, from 1.8% to 1.5%. Around Lake Tahoe and Truckee it reached 6.9%.

Key numbers

4.9%
of policies dropped by insurers each year, 2019–2021, in ZIPs mostly in High or Very High zones
2.3% in 2015–2017
2.1×
the 2015–2017 rate in those ZIP codes
93 ZIP codes
1.5%
dropped by insurers in ZIPs with no homes in those zones, 2019–2021
1.8% in 2015–2017
6.9%
dropped by insurers each year around Lake Tahoe and Truckee, 2019–2021
2.5% in 2015–2017

Non-renewals rose where hazard zones cover the most homes

We grouped every ZIP code in the three regions by the share of its homes in a High or Very High zone. Before the 2018 Camp Fire, the most exposed ZIP codes already had a somewhat higher rate (2.3%, against 1.8% in ZIP codes with no homes in those zones). By 2019–2021 it had more than doubled there, while it slipped in ZIP codes with no homes in the zones.

2015–2017 2019–2021
Share of a ZIP code's homes in High or Very High zonesZIP codesHomes in High or Very High zonesDropped by insurers, 2015–20172019–2021Before / after
More than half9376.9%2.33%4.88%
10% to 50%6320.1%1.64%2.19%
Under 10%783.5%1.53%1.44%
No homes in High or Very High zones2020.0%1.76%1.50%

“Dropped by insurers” is the Department of Insurance’s insurer-initiated non-renewals, as a share of all policies up for renewal that year. Most non-renewals are started by homeowners themselves (a sale or a switch of insurer); those are not counted here.

South Lake Tahoe home among the pines with James Hardie ColorPlus siding by GVD Renovations
ColorPlus siding, new soffits and Anlin windows on a GVD job in South Lake Tahoe, 2026. Around Lake Tahoe and Truckee, insurers dropped 6.9% of policies a year in 2019–2021.

By region

The jump is concentrated in the Sierra foothills and the Tahoe basin. Across the Bay Area as a whole the rate barely moved (1.6% to 1.5%), because most of its homes are far from the zones; its hillside ZIP codes show up in the table below.

RegionZIP codesHomes in High or Very High zonesDropped by insurers, 2015–20172019–2021Before / after
Sacramento region1227.2%2.13%2.49%
Tahoe–Truckee1186.2%2.50%6.92%
Bay Area3036.3%1.56%1.54%
All three regions4367.7%1.72%1.88%

ZIP codes where insurers dropped the most policies

The highest rate was in Foresthill (95631) in Placer County: 14.4% of policies a year in 2019–2021, up from 3.4% in 2015–2017, with 94.0% of its homes in a High or Very High zone. Most of the ZIP codes at the top of the list are in the El Dorado and Placer County foothills.

ZIP codeRegionHomes in High or Very High zonesDropped by insurers, 2015–20172019–2021
Foresthill (95631)
Placer County
Sacramento region94.0%3.44%14.39%
Meadow Vista (95722)
Placer County
Sacramento region96.3%2.64%13.34%
Pollock Pines (95726)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region89.5%3.04%12.48%
Applegate (95703)
Placer County
Sacramento region58.1%2.77%12.37%
Pilot Hill (95664)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region70.5%4.57%12.06%
Colfax (95713)
Placer County
Sacramento region91.4%3.55%11.60%
Olympic Valley (96146)
Placer County
Tahoe–Truckee68.4%3.53%11.35%
Camino (95709)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region96.7%2.56%10.76%
Greenwood (95635)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region76.3%4.69%10.49%
Cool (95614)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region80.7%3.86%9.66%
Garden Valley (95633)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region89.1%4.77%9.53%
Alta (95701)
Placer County
Sacramento region96.1%4.03%9.52%
El Dorado (95623)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region86.1%3.17%9.49%
Georgetown (95634)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region88.6%4.76%9.36%
Auburn (95602)
Placer County
Sacramento region18.8%2.27%9.34%
Somerset (95684)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region85.3%4.46%8.91%
Placerville (95667)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region78.4%2.59%8.66%
Tahoe City (96145)
Placer County
Tahoe–Truckee87.7%3.15%7.92%
Kyburz (95720)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region21.3%2.97%7.88%
Lotus (95651)
El Dorado County
Sacramento region93.9%2.94%7.79%

ZIP codes with fewer than 200 policies up for renewal a year are left out. The full table, including 2020–2023 total non-renewals, is in the download.

Making your home easier to insure?

We replace siding, windows and roofs with fire-resistant materials, and check what your building department requires for your address before we quote.

(916) 269-0761

What this means for your home

The hazard maps don’t decide your insurance. The Department of Insurance says insurers use their own wildfire risk models, not CAL FIRE’s zones, to decide where to write and renew policies. The two track the same hillsides, which is why the numbers move together.

Under the state’s Safer from Wildfires rules, insurers have to recognize certain home and community mitigation in their rates. Our wildfire defense guide explains what counts and how to check your zone on the State Fire Marshal’s map. For how many homes sit in the zones and how old they are, see our hazard zone study.

Truckee home with James Hardie lap siding, a GVD Renovations project
Hardie lap siding on a GVD job in Truckee, 2023.

Method

Insurance data. The California Department of Insurance publishes new, renewed and non-renewed homeowners and dwelling-fire policies by ZIP code and year, from insurers that write about 98% of the market. Its 2015–2021 file splits non-renewals into insurer-initiated and insured-initiated. We use the insurer-initiated count, divided by all policies up for renewal (renewed plus both kinds of non-renewal), pooled over 2015–2017 and 2019–2021.

Hazard zones. For each ZIP code we used our count of homes in CAL FIRE High or Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones from our hazard zone study, summed over Census blocks in the matching ZIP Code Tabulation Area.

Checks. In the Department’s file, insurer-initiated non-renewals are 20.3% of all non-renewals statewide in 2015–2021, in line with the Department’s own figure of 20–25%. All 436 ZIP codes in our study area matched a ZIP in the insurance data.

Limits

  • The insurer-initiated split stops in 2021. The Department’s 2020–2023 file counts all non-renewals together, most of them started by homeowners, so we show it only as “total non-renewals” in the download. The two files also count policies somewhat differently, so we don’t combine them.
  • The hazard zones are the 2024–2025 maps; the insurance data is from earlier years. The comparison shows where non-renewals happened, not that the maps caused them.
  • ZIP codes and Census ZIP Code Tabulation Areas don’t match exactly, and for ZIP codes on the edge of our study area the hazard share covers only the part inside it.
  • The data covers the regular (voluntary) market, not the FAIR Plan, and excludes renters and condo policies.

Download the data and cite this study

The full ZIP code table can be used by anyone under a CC BY 4.0 license. Please credit GVD Renovations and link to this page.

Download CSV
Cite as
GVD Renovations. "Are Insurers Dropping Homes in Wildfire Zones? Non-Renewals by ZIP Code in Sacramento, Tahoe and the Bay Area" 2026. Data: California Department of Insurance; CAL FIRE Fire Hazard Severity Zones; U.S. Census Bureau. https://www.gvdrenovationsinc.com/research/home-insurance-nonrenewals-wildfire-zones/

Found an error? Tell us with the source; we’ll fix it and add a dated note on this page.

Sources

4.9921+ Reviews

Getting a home ready for fire season?

We replace siding, windows and roofs with fire-resistant materials across the Sacramento region, Lake Tahoe and the Bay Area.

What happens next
  1. 1
    Free consultation
    We visit, listen, measure and talk through your budget. No pressure.
  2. 2
    Design & written proposal
    Your design, materials and a detailed fixed-price proposal before anything starts.
  3. 3
    Build with your project manager
    A dedicated project manager and in-house crews from start to finish.
Prefer to talk?(916) 269-0761
Licensed & insured · CA License #989637
Get Your Free Estimate

Request a free, no-obligation quote and expert advice.

No obligation, no pressure